By on August 15, 2013

extravirgin_mapPlace: Extra Virgin

Neighborhood: West Village, 259 W 4th St. (between Charles St. & Perry St.)

Mimosa Rating:

4 mimosas

The scoop: Extra Virgin is another brunch staple in the West Village and is usually packed regardless of the day or time of year. You often see people hanging out around the outside waiting to get in. Even on a day reaching 90-plus degrees, there were people willing to sit outside to get a taste of the delicious food.

Outside Extra Virgin on a hot day

Outside Extra Virgin on a hot day

It actually wasn’t super busy when we got there. It was pretty early in the day, though. The bar can get busy with single diners and those just wanting a cocktail. The restaurant itself is a small, dimly lit energetic spot — perfect for dates, yet also a great place to catch up with some close friends. It is not as loud during brunch as it is during dinner. The modestly priced menu seems even lower than the average West Village brunch spot, so no complaints there!

The service started out pretty great but slowly declined. The server never checked back on us during our meal, which doesn’t usually bother me. She never brought the bill until we finally motioned for her to come over. We attempted to split the bill five ways, but something went wrong and this didn’t go as planned. Again, things like this happen in restaurants, but it all comes down to how they handle it. It took awhile to get payment straightened out, and we had to speak with two different people.

Fresh bread and EVOO

Fresh bread and EVOO

Bottoms up: After a long weekend in Montauk, we decided that drinking was not the best option! However, Extra Virgin does have delicious-sounding summer cocktails for around $12.

Chew on this:

Fresh bread and olive oil / Complimentary

Be sure not to skip out on the complimentary fresh bread and olive oil. This place is called Extra Virgin after all!

Baked Eggs

Baked Eggs

Baked Eggs $14 / Pancetta, spinach, roasted tomato hollandaise

This is hands down the best dish out of all the amazing dishes we had. It was an interesting twist on an egg dish. I have not had hollandaise in a dish other than eggs Benedict. The sauce added a fantastic creamy touch. The pancetta, tomato and spinach soaked up nicely with the baked runny eggs, as did the bread baked under everything. The bread in the dish was a pleasant surprise since it wasn’t mentioned in the list of ingredients. This entrée was served in an oven-baked dish and was just delicious all around.  Get this if you’re an eggs Benedict fan, but want something a little different.

Basque Scramble

Basque Scramble

Basque Scramble $14 / Peperonata, creamy polenta, salsa verde, avocado purée, chorizo

Between the peperonata and the chorizo, there was a bold blend of flavor and even a little spice to this dish. The mixture really worked well together. There was delicious avocado purée and salsa dolloped on top. You really can’t go wrong with this one. This dish is also pretty generously portioned.

Banana French Toast

Banana French Toast

Banana French Toast $14 / Caramelized bananas, whipped mascarpone

This is an extremely rich and decadent dish — everyone raves about it. After my friend’s amazing description of it, I had to order it. The caramelized bananas are sprinkled over the French toast and maple syrup is drizzled all over. It was right up my alley! The mascarpone cheese melted over the warm pieces of toast and created a creamy ice cream-like texture. Order this dish if you’re in the mood for something sweet. 

Extra Virgin

Extra Virgin

Extra Virgin $11 / Baby arugula, cucumber, tomato, red onion, avocado, grilled bread, Chianti vinegar

If you want a great starter or something really fresh, this dish is for you. This was a great veggie salad with amazing dressing. The salad has even amounts of all of the veggies listed, particularly the avocado.

Virgin Frittata

Virgin Frittata

Virgin Frittata $13 / Goat cheese, roasted tomato, arugula, basil pesto

This dish is a real winner! It’s light yet is generously portioned much like the scramble. My friend had difficulty finishing it. The goat cheese and pesto were not overwhelming and provided outstanding flavor with the perfectly cooked eggs. This is a great dish to order, even if you aren’t a vegetarian. 

A rare quiet time during brunch

A rare quiet time during brunch

The final bite: Extra Virgin has delicious quality food and a pleasant atmosphere. It’s one of West Village’s quintessential brunch spots, so be sure to check it out. I know I will be back!

Reviewed by: Erica

Red Rooster

April 12, 2017

Bespoke Kitchen

March 12, 2017


February 1, 2015


January 11, 2015

Favela Cubana

June 26, 2014

Corkbuzz Wine Studio

May 7, 2014

Tammany Hall

April 14, 2014


March 13, 2014

Lobster Joint

March 11, 2014



Subscribe to updates!
Never miss out on the latest brunch reviews and deals by subscribing to the Brunchgang newsletter!
Follow Brunchgang on Twitter
Recent Posts